Banyan Hill Publishing – Scam or Legit? Reviews, Complaints And The TRUTH!

Banyan Hill Publishing is a multi-million dollar publishing company that specializes in subscription-based investment newsletters (often sold with the portrayal of providing easy ways to make money through “little-known” means) and it’s owned by a large group named The Agora.

Banyan Hill Publishing Website Screenshot

The Agora, who own Banyan Hill also owns a publishing company named Agora Financial too & their marketing style is similar to Banyan Hill’s in the sense that a lot of their products suggest you could potentially sign up & learn how to make lots of money with ease…

But naturally, this marketing style has drawn a lot of attention, and also a lot of complaints… So what’s the TRUTH? Is Banyan Hill a scam? Or is it a legitimate company & can you really make money with their advice?

Those are the exact questions I’ll be uncovering the answers to in this review, as well as bringing to light some interesting third party Banyan Hill Publishing reviews, complaints & performance information. So basically if you’ve been thinking about getting involved with them you can rest assured that you’ve landed in the right place to find out everything you need to know before you do. ?

Before I start though if you want to go straight to my no.1 LEGIT recommendation for making money then you can check it out via the link below:

Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

(This is a 100% free training for making 5-figures per month)

Quick Navigation

I really have gone all-out & took a truly in-depth look into Banyan Hill Publishing & The Agora (their parent company) to find out everything you need to know, but as a result it means that this review is going to be pretty detailed… So, to make things easier for you I’ve decided to put together a little table of contents below which you can use to quickly navigate to the information that you’re specifically looking for. ?

Who Is Banyan Hill Publishing?

So as I touched on at the very start of this review, Banyan Hill Publishing is part of a group named The Agora – they fall underneath their (rather large) umbrella along with another company named Agora Financial, which also publishes similar newsletters to that of Banyan Hill.

The Agora, which was formerly known as Agora, Inc came to be way back in 1978, but it wasn’t until 1998 when Banyan Hill Publishing itself was launched, originally under the name of The Sovereign Society.

Initially, they launched as a company providing US citizens with global investment advice in an effort to help them diversify their investments outside of the US Dollar… But then in 2016, they rebranded to become Banyan Hill Publishing, whilst also changing their strategy & this time putting a focus on actually prioritizing US-based investments instead.

Their US-based investments opportunities include investments in things like commodities, natural resources, small/mid-cap stocks, options plays & domestic companies.

RECOMMENDED: Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

And it’s safe to say that as a publishing company they’ve been pretty successful, with their content getting an alleged 400,000 daily readers & their company growing from turning over $6 million per year to a whopping $113 million per year in the last three years alone…

BUT despite the financial growth, it hasn’t been all plain-sailing for Banyan Hill… Their company has received a LOT of complaints, and there have even been several Banyan Hill Publishing scam rumours spread across the web with people saying that they’re purely focused on using “tricks” to part people with their cash rather than actually focused on providing useful investment advice…

The truth about that will be uncovered further in this review, but in my opinion – I can see where some of such allegations have arisen from as Banyan Hill has a “questionable” marketing approach to say the least… Though, they do deliver on their promise in terms of what they provide (only the opportunities may not be as lucrative as they initially seem).

And sadly in some cases, the seemingly “profitable” opportunities they provide may actually result in nothing other than losses… But as I say I’ll speak more about that as we progress through the review.


A Look Into Banyan Hill’s Newsletters

Banyan Hill Publishing has several top financial analysts working with them, such as the likes of Matt Badiali & Paul Mampilly, and as a result, they offer out many different newsletters.

Some of the most popular newsletters include the likes of Matt Badiali’s Real Wealth Strategist, Paul Mampilly’s Profits Unlimited & the Bauman Letter by Ted Bauman… But that’s by no means an exhaustive list – they have much more premium content such as that which I’ve listed below:

  • Matt Badiali’s Real Wealth Strategist
  • Ted Bauman’s Plan B Club
  • The $10 Million Portfolio With Ian Dyer and Paul Mampilly
  • Rapid Profit Trader With Ian Dyer and Paul Mampilly
  • Ian King’s Crypto Profit Trader
  • Matt Badiali’s Front Line Profits
  • Michael Carrs’ Peak Velocity Trader
  • Paul Mampilly’s True Momentum
  • Paul Mampilly’s Extreme Fortunes
  • Chad Shoop’s Quick Hit Profits
  • Ted Bauman’s Alpha Stock Alert
  • Chad Shoop’s Automatic Profits Alert
  • Paul Mampilly’s Profits Unlimited
  • The Bauman Letter By Ted Bauman
  • The Bauman Letter Elite By Ted Bauman
  • Jeff Yastine’s Total Wealth Insider
  • The Freedom Alliance by Robert Bauman
  • Chad Shoop’s Pure Income
  • Michael Carr’s Precision Profits

Now one thing I’d like to point out about the newsletters above is that they are often branded in their own right – so rather than being hosted or sold through the Banyan Hill Publishing website, many of them are often sold through their very own separate websites as “stand-alone” products.

In fact, in some instances, it’s possible that you might not even know the investment newsletter that you are buying into is actually associated with Banyan Hill until you get to the subscription purchase page that is…

RECOMMENDED: Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

Some of them though, like Ted Bauman’s Plan B club, for example, are indeed sold through the Banyan Hill website – but at the present time as I write this review that is literally the only newsletter (or piece of “premium content”) that you can actually opt to subscribe to directly via their main website.

Banyan Hill Newsletters

As to why that is the case I’m not quite sure – in my opinion, it seems quite strange…

You would, as is the case with any normal publishing company, expect to just be able to visit their main website & subscribe to the newsletter/content of your choice but rather oddly that doesn’t seem to be the case at Banyan Hill.

And another thing I’d like to point out is that often multiple newsletters come bundled together – so let’s say (purely as an example) that you decided to buy a subscription to Paul Mampilly’s True Momentum newsletter, it would be very advisable to closely look over the checkout page to make sure you are being “discreetly” bundled into another subscription.

The reason I’m pointing that out is that it’s something that’s been at the centre of many of the Banyan Hill Publishing complaints which is exactly what I’m going to move onto talking about next…

Banyan Hill Publishing Complaints

As I mentioned at the very start of this review, Banyan Hill has, in my opinion, a “questionable” method of marketing to say the least & as a result, this seems to have led to quite a few complaints…

For example, often their products (again in my opinion) are often marketed with the portrayal of potentially providing an opportunity to get rich quickly & easily, without much risk.

So naturally, a lot of people buy into them expecting a real certified money-maker, but in actual fact, that’s often not the case… And in many instances, it seems their customers have actually just gone on to LOSE money rather than make it – and sometimes a LOT of money too.

Now, this doesn’t mean I’m saying Banyan Hill aren’t legit (I’m not saying that – they are legit), however, I just wanted to bring what some of what their customers have had to say about the company to your attention, as naturally if you’re considering investing money into them you’re likely going to want to know about the Banyan Hill complaints.

RECOMMENDED: Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

But, as I mentioned above, Banyan Hill is indeed technically legit – and I think the fact that they’re turning over a whopping $113 million per year proves that because with that much exposure if something untoward was going on I’m pretty sure they’d have been forced to close their doors a long time ago.

They sell publications – and that’s what they provide… In my opinion, it’s just the way they sell them that’s causing the controversy (and Agora Financial their “sister” also markets it’s publications in a similar style too).

Anyway, take a look at what some of these folks have had to say over at the BBB:

Banyan Hill Publishing Complaint 1

Banyan Hill Publishing Complaint 2

Banyan Hill Publishing Complaint 3

So yeah – the primary problems seem to be;

  • Problems/difficult cancelling the subscriptions
  • Being billed more times than expected
  • Recommendations generating losses rather than profits
  • Pushed into spending more money to “upgrade”

What I will point out though is that Banyan Hill Publishing had resolved every complaint that I came across with a full refund – however, in the event of losses from trading, the loss was NOT refunded – only the cost of the subscription associated with the advice.

Banyan Hill stated the following response to the customer who asked for “damages” to be refunded:

There will be no additional refund as you were fully aware of the risks that come with investing before you joined each of the services you bought this year.

Also, something odd I noticed is that Banyan Hill Publishing’s business primarily revolves around publishing investment-related newsletters which promise the potential to build wealth, yet the disclaimer on their website states “Nothing herein should be considered personalized investment advice“.

Some Interesting Banyan Hill Reviews

Whilst carrying out my research I decided to run a Google search for some Banyan Hill Publishing reviews to see what others had to say about the company – preferably people who had long-term experience following the advice published in their newsletters… And what I found was “interesting” to say the least…

Firstly, I came across some reviews on a website called RepDigger at which Banyan Hill scored a shocking 1% reputation score as shown below:

Banyan Hill Publishing Reviews 1

Now as you can imagine arriving at that score most of the reviews on that particular site were negative (very negative actually!) but there was ONE positive review which read:

Banyan Hill Publishing Reviews 2

However, there was also a question posted on Quora entitled “is Banyan Hill a scam?” and this answer posted recently on Oct 2 was shown towards the top of the page:

Banyan Hill Scam

In my opinion, though the comment shown above which was left by Eoj Mihkiel on Quora is potentially “over the top” to say the least – after all, can you really call a “forgotten about” subscription a scam?

If you subscribe to a product or service, elderly or not, then your subscription to that product/service will continually re-bill until it is cancelled – since the company providing it will assume that you’re still utilizing it.

I think in that particular instance calling it a “scam” is a bit harsh, to say the least.

If you contact the company & they stop billing – all is fair & well (which it seems is what happened)… Sure, it’s not nice forgetting about a subscription and realizing you have been getting billed – but ultimately you have to realize your mistake and move on.

If however they refused to cancel the subscription or said they would cancel and didn’t – THEN it could be potentially deemed a scam.

But anyway that brings me onto…

Is Banyan Hill a Scam?

Definitely not – I mean sure, they may have their questionable marketing tactics & potential problems with re-billing but they are definitely NOT a scam by any means at all.

At the end of the day, they sell access to newsletters & that’s what they provide – they also provide investment advice, and of course, it would be silly to take any investment advice as a guaranteed way to make money.

So ultimately when you are subscribing to a company like Banyan Hill or Agora Financial you are likely doing so for 1 of 2 reasons, which are that you either purely want the information to simply digest – or you want to act on the information, knowing that it involves RISK.

Sure, you may turn a profit – but you may not – and in the instances of the advice offered through companies like Banyan Hill (advice that talks about BIG returns), then the risk will be a lot higher, because naturally, the potential of bigger returns involves bigger risk.

RECOMMENDED: Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

If it was so easy to turn such a large profit through investing then everybody would be doing it – nobody would be working a job, but sadly it’s not so easy… It’s the total opposite.

But what is one of the best ways to potentially “make it big” through investing? Well, I would like to think one of the best ways would be to listen to the advice of a professional, expert financial analyst – which is exactly what Banyan Hill provides you with access to.

Therefore Banyan Hill is not a scam – it is a legitimate company in terms of what it offers & what it provides… However, in my opinion, I do feel that the marketing material could highlight the risk involved more prominently and that it could also refrain from hyping the opportunities up so much.

I appreciate that it’s easy for those who don’t know a great deal about investing to be misled into thinking that it’s something that it’s not, or that it’s easier to profit than it actually is…

So yeah, Banyan Hill is legit – but in my opinion, their marketing could be worked upon.

My Verdict on Banyan Hill Publishing

If you’re looking to invest money & you want something that could potentially provide more returns than the traditional routes (such as investing through the likes of Ken Fisher Investments) & you know full well about the risks involved – then Banyan Hill Publishing could provide you with exactly that.

They give you access to the advice & “picks” put out by some of the worlds top financial analysts such as the likes of Matt Badiali, Paul Mampilly, Ted Bauman & many more…

It is by no means a guaranteed way to make money, and judging from some of the external Banyan Hill reviews it’s likely that you could end up losing more than you ever make, BUT if one pick did end up coming in, then you could indeed turn a substantial profit.

Bigger profits = bigger risks, that’s the bottom line…

So if you’re down to your last dollar & you’re looking into one of Banyan Hill’s newsletters as a potential “way out” then I’d advise you think again and be wiser with your money… But if you have money that you can afford to lose, and you’re not relying on the returns then you may be interested in “trying” some of the picks offered via Banyan Hill.

However, as I mentioned towards the start of this review I would advise you to take caution when taking out a subscription via Banyan Hill as often many of their products come “bundled” together & this would only be picked up on if you take notice of the small print… You don’t want to end up getting billed for more products than you intended to purchase.

I’m not saying don’t buy them – I’m just saying buy carefully if you do decide to buy.

A Better Way To Make Good Money

If you’ve landed at this review to find out more about Banyan Hill Publishing then I can only assume that you’re looking for a way to build up some additional income OR maybe you weren’t, but after coming across one of Banyan Hill’s pitches you’ve now gotten interested in it…

Well, I’m not gonna lie, whilst Banyan Hill Publishing might be legit – I personally feel that there is a BETTER way to build an additional income – one that doesn’t involve risk like investing.

I know that might sound a little crazy – after all, how could you build up a better income without risk? But that’s why I’ve put a page together on this website which explains it in more detail for you to get a better understanding.

So if the sound of that interests you then be sure to check out my no.1 recommendation below:

Go here to see my no.1 recommendation for making money online

(This is a 100% free training showing you how I make 5-figures per month)

15 thoughts on “Banyan Hill Publishing – Scam or Legit? Reviews, Complaints And The TRUTH!”

  1. Well, please respond. A couple of days ago I came across this video put out by Mampily. He was talking about a stock or a company in the forefront of developing blockchain technology and the stock is trading a little over ten$ , that company is in acceptance phase he was showing some desolate warehouses that the technology is being developed but to to strike rich you had to act before the end of March so wow I bought the subscription to find out what this great and mysterious stock was and as it turns out he was talking about AMD, Granted I love the stock and have made handsome profits by trading it on and off BUT AMD is not a secret company not does it trade at 10$My point is why me. Mampily uses this old old narrative to intice fools like me. Don’t get me wrong AMD is a great stock to have. He is either a prophet who saw AMD’s rise years ago and made this video or he is a charlatan who recently made this video to intice people to subscribe to their service you be the judge and I am itching to know what your thought is on this phenomenon. Thank you

    • Hi Naseem, I have heard about the same thing happening across many of these subscription products by Banyan Hill Publishing. In my opinion their whole marketing approach seems to be to build massive hype around okay/average investments. That way they can lure people in, get subscription money & not get any comeback as what they said (although massively hyped) is true by technicality. If all of their investment ideas worked as they portray them to then we’d all be becoming overnight millionaires… Sadly they don’t but you only get to find that out after purchasing.

  2. I do not recommend this company. They sell NL and subscriptions, but for your money’s worth from the info, you always need to buy another publication or service. It would be nice to have the pub I purchased central for its stated purpose, not a “paid” organ to suck me in on other offers. Secondly, they do not reveal the dollar level cost of the investments they make money on– it appears the actual threshold is always much more that minimal. They should provice the bottom level threshold, to smaller investor know what they ‘cannot’ afford.

  3. i watched a video of Paul Mampilly nice work-life story , he was a wall street wizard made a fortune now offering his knowledge and experience because he cares for the main street guy. In the video, he stated he would mention the geothermal co getting ready to take off and investors will start making big money if you get in now. Well, he never really did mention it except in location and some pics of plant, this is called deceptive business practice. As the old saying goes, if its to good to be true, then it probably is. Been there done that, with another subscription investing co, called Motley Fool. Bad experience, more losses than gains. Theres a name for people that repeat the same mistake twice. This publishing co maybe legit, but its untruthful, unethical,and in who best interest are they looking out for, theirs or the customer/ investor?.

  4. I subscribed to the entry-level newsletter, and immediately they were calling and emailing trying to get me to sign up for other subscriptions that were 1000’s of dollars. I wanted to see how well they delivered on the hype they put into the low level newsletter. Well, the picks they had were pretty awful. They offered a printed newsletter showing past recommendations. My existing portfolio of my own picks were out performing their portfolio by a big margin. When the newsletter comes in the mail now I don’t even open it, that’s how valuable I find it. BUT! What’s worse they had had actually charged my credit card for and additional service, and my bank actually had them flagged, because they approached me about the charge as being potential fraud. The bank reversed the charge, and issued me a new card as a result. 100% scam. No Doubt!

  5. what about Charles Mizrahi? He has a great promo… and cheap, $49… Thanks, Neal Hugh Hurwitz, NY NY, Medellin, Israel. (phone number removed by admin).

    • Same story Neal – the price is low on the front but really that’s just a hook. After spending the initial fee you’ll be pressured into spending more & more. Also, I’ve removed your phone number from your comment, it’s never a good idea to post a phone number publicly online.

  6. I had a subscription to Boom & Bust, a newsletter by Dent Research. I haven’t received the letters or had any emails since 3/31/2020. I began researching and found that Banyon Hill dumped Dent Research, and apparently didn’t give Dent the subscriber lists. I haven’t heard from Banyon Hill, and it appears that I have nothing for my subscription.
    You would think Banyon would email everyone on the subscriber list and tell us what was happening, but not a word as of 5/1/2020. Sounds like a shady business if not a total fraud! I will definitely avoid Banyon Hill and Agora Financial from here on out. I’m retired and can’t afford to throw money away!

  7. I recently signed up for Paul Mampilly’s Newsletter and his recommendation for Rambus (RMBS) has gone up more than 20% in a month. The warning about past investing is no guarantee of future returns…blah, blah blah, is something all investing recommendations come with. These guys have already made their fortune and they are collecting a HUGE monthly check from subscriptions now. I can’t be mad at a person who has spent their life learning how to make money and offering to share that advice for a fee if they are up front about it as Banyan is. I really see how the next five years will explode some small companies who are creating product for the coming Internet of Things (IoT), AI, and 5G. Mampilly has some great buy suggestions, and that’s what they all provide, suggestions. I am an over qualified 60 year old who cannot even get an interview for a job so I have been playing with my brokerage account to secure my retirement (My cheating spouse divorced me when I was 50 and destroyed me financially) and I have been cautious and happy with my small investments so far. This is the eighth site I have been to searching for people who have had bad experiences with Banyan before I dropped $2K for Chad Shoop’s Quick Hits on buying Options. The guy is very well respected out there. I have read about 95% positive on Shoop but $2K is a lot of money to me these days. We all have to assume the risk we are comfortable with and my view is to be smart, investigate and make educated guesses before buying, and hope for the best. There are $10 and below stocks out there that will explode like Google, Facebook, and Netflix with the IoT and 5G so us little guys can make a killing in the next five years. I only made quick money when I was a 15 year old coke dealer in LA in the 70’s but the fear of getting caught made me quit. Find the risk you can live with. Good buying and all the best.

    • I would advise caution with Banyan Hill Publishing reviews at the moment as it seems there is something very suspicious going on. The company had a ton of 1-star negative reviews on TrustPilot & then all of a sudden out of nowhere a flood of positive reviews have come in, all published on the exact same day.

  8. Hi Dale! I took the bait on Mampilly’s video and subscribed to PROFITS UNLIMITED. Immediately, I experienced the UP-SELL, just to access the coveted “list” of the golden opportunities; I should have bailed by day three. Unfortunately, when I finally accessed the website, I realized I had been duped! I was shown the books I needed and wanted but alas, the “click here” to read, does not work. I suppose $495.00 is just the entry fee!


Leave a Comment

This website is reader-supported. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More